‘Shields here but unable to respond’: Gardiner Veterans Day ceremony recalls Seabee

GARDINER — About 150 people joined a small group of Seabees to commemorate Veterans Day on an isolated, bucolic hill in a special place.

The Gardiner Cemetery is the final resting place of Marvin G. Shields, a Port Townsend resident killed in battle in Vietnam in 1965 at the age of 25 and the only Seabee to ever receive the Medal of Honor, the highest military accolade.

Seabees — members of the Navy’s mobile construction battalion — from Whidbey Island, Everett, Bangor and Bremerton gathered with active-duty service people in the cleared area with a view of Discovery Bay where Shields’ headstone had the most prominent display.

The 20-minute ceremony included a roll call in which a Seabee in the crowd returned the call: “Construction Mechanic 3rd Class Shields is here but unable to respond.”

Shields’ widow, Joan Bennett of Gardiner, and his brother, Don Shields of Quilcene, represented the family.

Don Shields, a retired mechanic, remembered his brother as “a cool dude.”

“He always had his hands out ready to help,” he said.

“If he were alive today, he would still be working hard to provide the best for his family.”

Thursday’s ceremony was the 44th annual celebration of Shields’ heroic accomplishments.

Wounded in battle

On June 10, 1965, the Seabee construction mechanic 3rd class was among those building an Army Special Forces compound in Dong Xoai, 55 miles north of Saigon, when the outpost was attacked by 1,500 Vietcong.

Wounded twice himself, Shields carried a severely wounded man to safety and then volunteered to assist in knocking out an enemy machine gun emplacement.

The machine-gun nest was destroyed. Shields was shot again, mortally wounded.

The Port Townsend American Legion Post 26 is named for Shields. A ceremony also was held there Thursday, with Police Chief Conner Daily as the guest speaker and a concert by the Port Townsend Summer Band.

‘Beyond combat’

In his invocation at the Gardiner ceremony, Chaplain Ken Johnson said he hoped that those present “one day could move us beyond combat to affirm all human life.”

Shields’ Medal of Honor citation was read, and there was a reading of the watch.

It ended with a slow rendition of taps played by two buglers, one with the main melody line and another playing accent lines in response as if it were an echo.

Given the isolated location and the spellbound crowd, the music was the only sound at the time and set a somber yet exhilarating mood.

After Dan Van Natta, master of ceremonies, ended the tribute on a solemn note, he returned a few minutes to suggest that anyone who was up for a bite to eat should join the Seabees for lunch at Fat Smitty’s down the road.

The renowned burger joint is owned by veteran Carl “Fat Smitty” Schmidt and was open for Veterans Day.

“I wanted to say this at the end of the ceremony but it didn’t seem right to follow taps with an announcement that we should meet over at Fat Smitty’s,” Van Natta said.

________

Jefferson County Reporter Charlie Bermant can be reached at 360-385-2335 or charlie.bermant@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Crews work to remove metal siding on the north side of Field Arts & Events Hall on Thursday in Port Angeles. The siding is being removed so it can be replaced. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Siding to be replaced

Crews work to remove metal siding on the north side of Field… Continue reading

Tsunami study provides advice

Results to be discussed on Jan. 20 at Field Hall

Chef Arran Stark speaks with attendees as they eat ratatouille — mixed roasted vegetables and roasted delicata squash — that he prepared in his cooking with vegetables class. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Nonprofit school is cooking at fairgrounds

Remaining lectures to cover how to prepare salmon and chicken

Port Townsend Main Street Program volunteers, from left, Amy Jordan, Gillian Amas and Sue Authur, and Main Street employees, Sasha Landes, on the ladder, and marketing director Eryn Smith, spend a rainy morning decorating the community Christmas tree at the Haller Fountain on Wednesday. The tree will be lit at 4 p.m. Saturday following Santa’s arrival by the Kiwanis choo choo train. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Decoration preparation

Port Townsend Main Street Program volunteers, from left, Amy Jordan, Gillian Amas… Continue reading

Port Angeles approves balanced $200M budget

City investing in savings for capital projects

Olympic Medical Center Board President Ann Henninger, left, recognizes commissioner Jean Hordyk on Wednesday as she steps down after 30 years on the board. Hordyk, who was first elected in 1995, was honored during the meeting. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
OMC Commissioners to start recording meetings

Video, audio to be available online

Jefferson PUD plans to keep Sims Way project overhead

Cost significantly reduced in joint effort with port, city

Committee members sought for ‘For’ and ‘Against’ statements

The Clallam County commissioners are seeking county residents to… Continue reading

Christopher Thomsen, portraying Santa Claus, holds a corgi mix named Lizzie on Saturday at the Airport Garden Center in Port Angeles. All proceeds from the event were donated to the Peninsula Friends of Animals. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Santa Paws

Christopher Thomsen, portraying Santa Claus, holds a corgi mix named Lizzie on… Continue reading

Peninsula lawmakers await budget

Gov. Ferguson to release supplemental plan this month

Clallam County looks to pass deficit budget

Agency sees about 7 percent rise over 2025 in expenditures

Officer testifies bullet lodged in car’s pillar

Witness says she heard gunfire at Port Angeles park