Although the water and air were both 43 degrees, 55 brave souls took the plunge during the 25th year of the Mystery Bay Polar Bear Dip on Marrowstone Island on Tuesday. (Jeannie McMacken/Peninsula Daily News)

Although the water and air were both 43 degrees, 55 brave souls took the plunge during the 25th year of the Mystery Bay Polar Bear Dip on Marrowstone Island on Tuesday. (Jeannie McMacken/Peninsula Daily News)

Making a splash: Plunge a mystery to some jumping into Mystery Bay

NORDLAND — For the past 25 years on Marrowstone Island, something comes over people on New Year’s Day.

They are driven to jump into Mystery Bay.

Why is perhaps the mystery.

Tom and Sue Rose, proprietors of the Nordland General Store, offer the opportunity to anyone who desires to take a plunge — called the Polar Bear Dip — to start the new year with a baptismal-like cleanse, washing off the accumulation of the previous year.

This year, at precisely noon as has been the tradition, a group of tentative jumpers lined the Roses’ dock and thought about it before they dove in, most emoting screams or laughter. As time passed, more lined up and went for it.

They were encouraged by a crowd of 50 people on shore who were not brave enough to follow suit, along with several kayakers and a paddleboarder.

An oompah band stationed on the general store’s front porch helped get everyone into the spirit.

According to Sue Rose, 55 people took the offer of her platform. It wasn’t cold enough to encourage big crowds, she said

“There were not as many jumpers as in the past,” she said. “I think they like to do it when it’s cold and wet and miserable.

“There’s no snow, no icebergs floating. That one really cold year, there was ice in the water. People showed up for that experience.”

Young and old, in various conditions and with varying skill levels, dove in, flopped in and tentatively eased into the water, estimated to be about 43 degrees Fahrenheit — the same temperature as the air.

Not everyone jumped at the same time. It took about 30 minutes for everyone wanting to plunge to complete the task. Sue Rose said some show up a few hours late to jump every year.

Crickett Webster of the Port Townsend-based Olympic Peninsula Steam Brass Screw Confederacy, said four of her group had planned to take the plunge together.

“I’m doing it because we all said we wanted to do it and never had. So, here we are. I’m afraid of cold water and I can’t believe I’m doing this,” Webster admitted.

Webster and her friends wore tutus. Nathan Barnett, president of the organization, wore a wool bathing suit. His handlebar moustache was waxed perfectly and held its shape after the dip.

Stephanie Worwag of Port Hadlock and her two nieces from Denver were eager to jump in.

“I’ve never done it before, and it’s a good question as to why I am here today,” Worwag said. “I wanted to do something new on the first day of the new year and this is it.”

Eric Johnson, a 1979 graduate of Port Townsend High School, has taken the Mystery Bay plunge for more than 20 years. His wife, Polleen, class of 1981, has done it for 10 years, the time they’ve been together.

“It’s tradition for me,” Eric Johnson said. “I come out and support the local community and be part of something.”

Polleen Johnson said she watched from shore the first year they were together.

“I said no way, but then watched and it looked like fun, even though it’s freezing cold,” she said. “And everyone was having a blast, so I said OK, I’ll do it.

“After, we’ll go home and get into our hot pond. He turned it up to 102 degrees F so it will be perfect by the time we get there.”

Steve Wixson made the trip from Sequim to start anew.

“My wife passed away a couple months ago from cancer so I’m starting the new year off with something that is a new start and I’ve never done it before,” he said.

Mark Stout of Nordland has taken the plunge before.

“I have a propensity for jumping in cold water at odd times,” he said. “There are no icebergs this year either. It will be eye-opening, to say the least.”

Pete Santerre and his son Cabot, 7, just moved to Port Townsend. This was their first time on the island.

“I’ve done this a couple times, before jumping off the Olalla Bridge in Port Orchard,” Santerre said. “But this is our first time up here. This is much more accessible for him which is great. Jumping off the bridge was a little too much for him, so last year he just ran in and out from the shore.”

This year, the pair was committed.

“We’re gonna hold hands, count 1-2-3 and jump in,” Santerre said before the big dip.

Cabot Santerre said he was really excited to be doing this with his dad, and the best part was “jumping in and getting cold.”

“I’ve got the towels prepped and the car will have the heater set to high,” his father said.

Scott Brinton of Nordland said he’s plunged five times. His daughter, 10-year old Cora, was hoping for her first experience.

“Me and my friend were going to do it last year, but I flaked out,” Cora Brinton said.

“I have no clue as to why I want to do this.”

________

Jefferson County Editor/Reporter Jeannie McMacken can be reached at 360-385-2335 or at jmcmacken@peninsuladailynews.com.

The initial shock of the cold water was expressed in many ways, including screaming and laughing, Tuesday during the Polar Bear Dip on Marrowstone Island. (Jeannie McMacken/Peninsula Daily News)

The initial shock of the cold water was expressed in many ways, including screaming and laughing, Tuesday during the Polar Bear Dip on Marrowstone Island. (Jeannie McMacken/Peninsula Daily News)

More in News

Port Townsend Main Street Program volunteers, from left, Amy Jordan, Gillian Amas and Sue Authur, and Main Street employees, Sasha Landes, on the ladder, and marketing director Eryn Smith, spend a rainy morning decorating the community Christmas tree at the Haller Fountain on Wednesday. The tree will be lit at 4 p.m. Saturday following Santa’s arrival by the Kiwanis choo choo train. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Decoration preparation

Port Townsend Main Street Program volunteers, from left, Amy Jordan, Gillian Amas… Continue reading

Port Angeles approves balanced $200M budget

City investing in savings for capital projects

Olympic Medical Center Board President Ann Henninger, left, recognizes commissioner Jean Hordyk on Wednesday as she steps down after 30 years on the board. Hordyk, who was first elected in 1995, was honored during the meeting. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
OMC Commissioners to start recording meetings

Video, audio to be available online

Jefferson PUD plans to keep Sims Way project overhead

Cost significantly reduced in joint effort with port, city

Committee members sought for ‘For’ and ‘Against’ statements

The Clallam County commissioners are seeking county residents to… Continue reading

Christopher Thomsen, portraying Santa Claus, holds a corgi mix named Lizzie on Saturday at the Airport Garden Center in Port Angeles. All proceeds from the event were donated to the Peninsula Friends of Animals. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Santa Paws

Christopher Thomsen, portraying Santa Claus, holds a corgi mix named Lizzie on… Continue reading

Peninsula lawmakers await budget

Gov. Ferguson to release supplemental plan this month

Clallam County looks to pass deficit budget

Agency sees about 7 percent rise over 2025 in expenditures

Officer testifies bullet lodged in car’s pillar

Witness says she heard gunfire at Port Angeles park

A copper rockfish caught as part of a state Department of Fish and Wildlife study in 2017. The distended eyes resulted from a pressure change as the fish was pulled up from a depth of 250 feet. (David B. Williams)
Author to highlight history of Puget Sound

Talk at PT Library to cover naming, battles, tribes

Vern Frykholm, who has made more than 500 appearances as George Washington since 2012, visits with Dave Spencer. Frykholm and 10 members of the New Dungeness Chapter, NSDAR, visited with about 30 veterans on Nov. 8, just ahead of Veterans Day. (New Dungeness Chapter DAR)
New Dungeness DAR visits veterans at senior facilities

Members of the New Dungeness Chapter, National Society Daughters of… Continue reading

Festival of Trees contest.
Contest: Vote for your favorite tree online

Olympic Medical Center Foundation’s Festival of Trees event goes through Dec. 25