Judge rules in favor of water pipeline to Marrowstone Island

PORT TOWNSEND — Marrowstone Island is entitled to a public water system.

So ruled visiting Clallam County Superior Court Judge Ken Williams, setting back a citizens group trying to stall a water pipeline to the island.

Williams’ ruling, unless appealed, clears the way for the PUD to pipe fresh water onto Marrowstone Island, cutting reliance on private water wells that are being fouled by sea water.

The matter was taken to court last May when a group of citizens, Conserve Water First, filed suit against the Jefferson County Public Utility District to stop the pipeline project.

Conserve Water First is led by Marrowstone residents Carrie and Rex Rice, and Wayne and Nicole Chimenti.

Intervening on behalf of the PUD was another citizens group, Water for Marrowstone, led by residents Ralph and Anne Rush, and Kelly and Gloria Hays.

“We’re obviously pleased,” PUD attorney Mary Winters said.

“The judge had done an excellent job of understanding the arguments of both parties and came to a fair and right decision.”

The opponents of the project have 30 days to appeal their lawsuit.

The attorney representing the Conserve Water First group did not return phone calls requesting comment.

The citizens group claimed the PUD violated the public process by improperly calculating the percentage of property owners who voted against the project in a poll taken just before commissioners approved the project in early 2004.

“Within a representative form of government, (PUD officials) are allowed to make such choices, so long as they follow the procedures required,” Williams said in his order.

“This they have done.”

More in News

Art Director Aviela Maynard quality checks a mushroom glow puzzle. (Beckett Pintair)
Port Townsend puzzle-maker produces wide range

Christmas, art-history and niche puzzles all made from wood

Food programs updating services

Report: Peninsula sees need more than those statewide

U.S. Rep. Emily Randall, D-Port Orchard.
Randall bill to support military families passes both chambers

ANCHOR legislation would require 45-day relocation notification

x
Home Fund supports rent, utility assistance

St. Vincent de Paul helps more than 1,220 Sequim families

EYE ON THE PENINSULA: Peninsula boards set to meet on Monday

Meetings across the North Olympic Peninsula

Hill Street in Port Angeles is closed due to a landslide. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Hill Street closed due to landslide

Hill Street is closed due to an active landslide.… Continue reading

Tippy Munger, an employee at Olympic Stationers on East Front Street in Port Angeles, puts out a welcoming display for holiday shoppers just outside the business’ door every day. She said several men have sat there waiting while their wives shop inside. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Holiday hijinks

Tippy Munger, an employee at Olympic Stationers on East Front Street in… Continue reading

Hospital begins recorded meetings

Board elects new officers for 2026

From left to right, Frank Hill, holding his dog Stoli, Joseph D. Jackson, Arnold Lee Warren, Executive Director Julia Cochrane, monitor Janet Dizick, holding dog Angel, Amanda Littlejohn, Fox and Scott Clark. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Winter Welcoming Center has expanded hours

Building provides respite from November through April

Wastewater bypass prompted no-contact advisory

The city of Port Angeles has clarified Monday’s wastewater… Continue reading

A crew from the Mason County PUD, in support of the Jefferson County PUD, works to replace a power pole and reconnect the power lines after a tree fell onto the wires and damaged the pole at the corner of Discovery Road and Cape George Road, near the Discovery Bay Golf Course. Powerful winds on Tuesday and early Wednesday morning knocked out power across the Peninsula. The majority had been restored by Wednesday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Reconnecting power

A crew from the Mason County PUD, in support of the Jefferson… Continue reading

Port Angeles council passes comp plan update

Officials debate ecological goals, tribal treaty rights