Port Angeles transient charged with attempted murder in Port Townsend stabbing

PORT TOWNSEND — A Port Angeles transient was charged with one count of attempted first degree murder Monday after an alleged stabbing attack Sunday morning in Port Townsend.

Matthew Robert Malone allegedly attacked a Port Townsend transient known to police as David Arbuckle.

Malone, 22, made his first appearance in Jefferson County Superior Court on Monday via video from the Jefferson County jail.

Judge Keith Harper set bail at $500,000. An arraignment is scheduled for Friday at 8:30 a.m.

“Based on the probable cause statement, based on allegations, that fact that you don’t live in the area and don’t have any connection to the immediate area, and allegedly went out of your way to come here, I think you are a high risk to not show up at this point,” said Harper.

“More importantly, you are an extreme risk of danger to the public. I impose a bail set today as requested of $500,000 cash or bond, along with the other conditions of release.”

Chief Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Julie St. Marie said the state will be filing a motion for a competency evaluation.

Malone has no Washington state felony history. He has several third-degree theft convictions in Clallam County from earlier this year. He will be represented by court-appointed attorney Ben Critchlow, a former public defender.

Arbuckle, 57, was airlifted to Harborview Medical Center in Seattle with multiple stab wounds on his upper back, shoulders and head.

Port Townsend Police Department spokesperson Keppie Keplinger said that as of Monday afternoon, Arbuckle’s condition was listed as stable and that he is expected to be in the hospital for a few more days.

Port Townsend police were called to the area of Quincy and Jefferson streets near Memorial Field at 9:16 a.m. Sunday to multiple reports of an assault involving two males.

According to a Port Townsend police report, Malone allegedly attacked Arbuckle in an unprovoked manner, “ostensibly at the direction of demons/spirits/angels who told him what to do.”

The report says Malone “purchased the knife used in the attack on Friday from Swains store in Port Angeles, specifically for the purpose of killing someone. He traveled by bus to Port Townsend in the early morning and apparently began looking for the right subject to attack.”

Malone told police that “he saw Arbuckle walking around town and followed him, as directed by the spirits. He attacked him from behind and stabbed him repeatedly with the ultimate goal of killing him,” according to the report.

Arbuckle was initially taken to Jefferson Healthcare hospital with stab wounds but was subsequently airlifted to Harborview for advanced trauma treatment.

Malone was taken into custody at the scene and transported to Jefferson Healthcare hospital for treatment of a minor laceration on a finger believed to have been self-inflicted during the attack. He was transported to the Jefferson County jail and booked.

The investigation is ongoing.

________

Jefferson County Editor/Reporter Jeannie McMacken can be reached at 360-385-2335 or at jmcmacken@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in Crime

Aaron Fisher, left, appears in Clallam County Superior Court on Jan. 9 with his attorney Lane Wolfley at a hearing during which his trial was confirmed to begin on Jan. 26. He has been charged with second-degree murder. (Clallam County Superior Court)
Murder trial is set for Jan. 26

Bank robbery trial to be reset for future date

Dozens of law enforcement vehicles assisted with the arrest of Justin Cox last June after he allegedly shot at officers and bystanders as he was sheltering inside a home. On Dec. 22, he received an order for civil commitment for inpatient psychiatric treatment. (Emily Matthiessen/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim man sent to state hospital

Charges could be refiled in Carlsborg standoff case

Cole Douglas, who was sentenced Thursday after he pleaded guilty to the March 2025 hit and run that seriously injured Sequim middle-schooler Colton Dufour, listens to Judge Elizabeth Stanley as Colton’s mother, Cherie Tachell, seated several rows back, smiles at her son just minutes before Douglas was taken into custody to begin serving a 12-month jail sentence. Seated beside them is victims advocate Molly Ramsey, who works in the Clallam County prosecuting attorney’s office and read a victim’s impact statement to the court during hearing. (Clallam County Superior Court)
Sequim man gets 1 year in hit-and-run

Teenager was seriously injured in March collision

Judge orders mental exam

Arraignment in murder case reset for late January

Couple investigated for identify theft, fraud

A Sequim couple has been arrested following an investigation… Continue reading

Jury selection Monday in child abuse case

Infant was found to have 11 fractures, including ribs, leg

Murder suspect returns to court

Charges refiled in his mother’s death

Montana man arrested three times in Clallam County in December

A 37-year-old Montana man was arrested three times last… Continue reading

Sheriff’s Office warns of payment requests scam related to jail

Multiple scam reports involving fraudulent payment requests have been… Continue reading

Financial scam targeting Peninsula residents, Sheriff’s Office says

North Olympic Peninsula residents have had more than $1… Continue reading

Robbery sentence set for 17 years

Reynolds pleads guilty to multiple charges

Tina Marie Alcorn, right, talks with attorney John Hayden during Alcorn’s first appearance on June 10, 2025, in Clallam County Superior Court after extradition from Arkansas in connection with the 2016 homicide of George Cecil David in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Woman sentenced in death of woodcarver

Tina Marie Alcorn pleads guilty to second-degree murder