Hearing reset for alleged murderers

PORT ANGELES — A review hearing for alleged murderers Benjamin Bonner and Shay Darrow was reset Thursday because a defense expert had not yet furnished a report.

Bonner and Darrow are charged in separate cases but have appeared together in recent hearings because their legal issues are nearly identical.

Bonner, 19, is charged with second-degree murder in the beating death of a family friend, Cynthia Little, in May 2017.

He has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity.

Darrow, 29, is charged with first-degree murder with with domestic violence for the shooting death of his father, Clint Darrow, in January 2017.

He intends to plead not guilty by reason of insanity, defense attorney John Hayden has said.

Hayden asked a defense psychologist to evaluate Bonner and Darrow to compel insanity evaluations at Western State Hospital.

Hayden reported Thursday that his expert had just returned from a vacation and was preparing a summary report.

“I expect it fairly soon,” Hayden said.

Clallam County Superior Court Judge Erik Rohrer reset the review hearing for May 3.

Bonner also is charged with first-degree animal cruelty first-degree robbery for allegedly killing Little’s dog and driving Little’s vehicle from her Sunland residence to his Bainbridge Island home.

Bonner is being held on $1.5 million bail.

Darrow is being held on $500,000 bail.

________

Reporter Rob Ollikainen can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 56450, or at rollikainen@peninsula dailynews.com.

More in Crime

Aaron Fisher, left, appears in Clallam County Superior Court on Jan. 9 with his attorney Lane Wolfley at a hearing during which his trial was confirmed to begin on Jan. 26. He has been charged with second-degree murder. (Clallam County Superior Court)
Murder trial is set for Jan. 26

Bank robbery trial to be reset for future date

Dozens of law enforcement vehicles assisted with the arrest of Justin Cox last June after he allegedly shot at officers and bystanders as he was sheltering inside a home. On Dec. 22, he received an order for civil commitment for inpatient psychiatric treatment. (Emily Matthiessen/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim man sent to state hospital

Charges could be refiled in Carlsborg standoff case

Cole Douglas, who was sentenced Thursday after he pleaded guilty to the March 2025 hit and run that seriously injured Sequim middle-schooler Colton Dufour, listens to Judge Elizabeth Stanley as Colton’s mother, Cherie Tachell, seated several rows back, smiles at her son just minutes before Douglas was taken into custody to begin serving a 12-month jail sentence. Seated beside them is victims advocate Molly Ramsey, who works in the Clallam County prosecuting attorney’s office and read a victim’s impact statement to the court during hearing. (Clallam County Superior Court)
Sequim man gets 1 year in hit-and-run

Teenager was seriously injured in March collision

Judge orders mental exam

Arraignment in murder case reset for late January

Couple investigated for identify theft, fraud

A Sequim couple has been arrested following an investigation… Continue reading

Jury selection Monday in child abuse case

Infant was found to have 11 fractures, including ribs, leg

Murder suspect returns to court

Charges refiled in his mother’s death

Montana man arrested three times in Clallam County in December

A 37-year-old Montana man was arrested three times last… Continue reading

Sheriff’s Office warns of payment requests scam related to jail

Multiple scam reports involving fraudulent payment requests have been… Continue reading

Financial scam targeting Peninsula residents, Sheriff’s Office says

North Olympic Peninsula residents have had more than $1… Continue reading

Robbery sentence set for 17 years

Reynolds pleads guilty to multiple charges

Tina Marie Alcorn, right, talks with attorney John Hayden during Alcorn’s first appearance on June 10, 2025, in Clallam County Superior Court after extradition from Arkansas in connection with the 2016 homicide of George Cecil David in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Woman sentenced in death of woodcarver

Tina Marie Alcorn pleads guilty to second-degree murder